The following divorce and refinance questions touch on the issues that are important when you're faced with either keeping the marital home or having your spouse buy you out.
Answers by Brette Sember, J.D. and Timothy McNamara, CDFA
There are several reasons why a person would choose to refinance their mortgage after a divorce. Here are some of the most common:
Ideally, the spouse taking ownership of the home needs to be solely responsible for the mortgage to avoid problems in the future. If you will be keeping the house and refinancing the mortgage, you’ll need to qualify for the mortgage based on your own income. You should carefully consider the pros and cons of refinancing and work with a reputable lender to ensure that your new mortgage meets your financial goals.
Find out if you should refinance the mortgage, how to get your share of the equity if your husband is the one who'll be refinancing, and what can be done if the mortgage isn't refinanced.
Should I refinance before or after divorce?
Denise's Question: I am in the planning stages of getting a divorce. The house we live in was purchased 14 years ago. We have a large amount of debt that could be eliminated by refinancing our house. I would like refinance the mortgage in my name and get him to sign a quitclaim deed so I could keep ownership of the house. Should I refinance the house before I file or after I file, and what other financial assets should I look at?
Timothy's Answer: You have many issues to consider while you are in the planning stages of a divorce. Your finances should be one of your top priorities. While your proposed division of assets may seem fair, are you comfortable with the long-term financial impact of your decision?
It is very common for women to have an emotional attachment to the family’s home, but I would urge you to consider whether you will be able to cover your mortgage obligation and the other expenses associated with maintaining a home on your own.
Your question about refinancing your house to pay off the debts is a good one. While it may seem an easy way to eliminate your debt, it may not be in your best interest. Before you initiate a refinancing and/or quit claim deed on your property, be sure you understand what you are getting into financially. Consider these questions:
I would highly recommend you hire a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst (CDFA) while you are planning your divorce. A CDFA will help you identify your marital assets, develop a post-divorce budget and advise you on the financial impact of any proposed division of marital assets. They can show you how your decisions will impact your after-tax cash flow and net worth today, in 5 years and well into the future. They provide valuable insights you are not likely to get elsewhere. The division of marital property is almost always permanent. It is imperative you make smart and informed decisions today so your interests are protected in the future.
Would it be wise to let him refinance if we might divorce?
Marge's Question: I was in a catastrophic car accident that left me with some physical disabilities and I got a settlement. Now all of the sudden he wants to refinance the house and take my name off the loan but not the deed, because he says his credit is better and he can get a better rate. I found out from a friend that he is talking about applying for jobs out of state (like 700 miles away). He told me that he cannot afford to keep paying high mortgage payments and he is running out of money. He keeps asking me for more money even though he was also paid from my settlement. Do you think it would be wise for me to let him refinance especially if we might split?
Brette's Answer: You should do absolutely nothing before speaking to an attorney.
Do I have to refinance if it wasn't required in the divorce?
Heather's Question: In my divorce it does not state that I have to refinance my home. It states I have to pay within 60 days of due date, I am responsible for taxes, insurance, etc. My ex wants his name off of the mortgage and the mortgage company says I have to refinance to do so. Can he force me to do this since it was not in the divorce?
Brette's Answer: No. If it is not in the decree, it is not something you are required to do. He could go back and ask for a modification of the order however.
Can he force me to refinance it it's not in our decree?
Angela's Question: My ex-husband and I divorced 17 years ago and his name has always been on the mortgage. I tried to refinance 9 years ago, but he and his wife said no, "because they weren't going to do anything nice for me that would make my life easier". Therefore, the refinance paperwork could not move forward. I hit a rough patch two years ago and my payments were late 10 times that year, but I have made the past 12 months of payments on time. Now he is on the war path to get his name off of the mortgage. His attorney sent a letter threatening to take my home because of the damage to my ex's credit report. It is not in our decree that I am ordered to refinance. Can he FORCE me to refinance (with closing cost and all)?
Brette's Answer: He's only entitled to what your decree gives him. Period. If he wants something else he has to seek it from the court. I would suggest you consult with your own attorney though because should he go to court, it could get expensive so it might make sense for you to settle this. Good luck.
Can I make him refinance the mortgage?
Linda's Question: Our separation agreement includes the following language: "The Husband shall be responsible for all costs related to the Home, including, but not limited to mortgage, taxes, insurance, maintenance and repairs and shall indemnify the Wife and hold her harmless as to any liabilities thereon." If my name is still on the mortgage, can I force my husband to refinance?
Brette's Answer: It is difficult to force someone to refinance because it's up to the bank whether he qualifies for a loan. What indemnification means is that if he fails to pay and the bank comes after you, you can in turn sue him for the costs you face. It's not a perfect situation.
Should I sign the quitclaim deed before my ex refinances?
Silke's Question: The house was mine in the decree. We are still both on the loan and on the deed. I am willing to sign the house over to him if he gets it refinanced. However, I don't want to sign the deed over and he never gets it refinanced. Can he get it refinanced BEFORE I sign the quit claim deed?
Brette's Answer: It can all happen simultaneously.
What if he refuses to sign the mortgage assumption papers?
Kristen's Question: My divorce was final over a year ago and in the decree it states that I would get the property title fee simple. The problem is my ex didn't show up for the final hearing and didn't sign a quitclaim deed. Now he won't cooperate and sign the loan assumption paper that the bank requires. Would the court find him in violation/contempt since he refuses?
Brette's Answer: Yes, that's your solution.
Can the mortgage company make me refinance?
Margarite's Question: We bought a house and my husband refinanced it in his name in 12 years later, with the deed remaining in both of our names. When we got divorced, I kept the house and he signed a quit claim deed transferring ownership to me. The mortgage company now wants me to refinance the loan in my own name. I pay the loan payments on time and I own the house, yet they want to charge me $17,000 to refinance the loan, instead of just letting me assume the payments. Is that legal?
Brette's Answer: I'm curious as to how the mortgage company even found out. That seems odd to me - they are usually happy to just be paid. Their problem is if you default they technically can only go after him since his name is the one on the mortgage. That puts them in an iffy position on ever collecting. They don't like the situation because it is messy. You might try asking for a supervisor there and explaining to them that you just want to assume the mortgage. That should be an option. If you can leave things as they are, that would be easiest. If not, you ought to shop the refinance around and get the best rate. Don't assume they're offering you the best deal. I'm not sure how a refinance can possibly cost you $17,000 up front. The fees should be much lower than that. Go to a couple banks and get some rates. Good luck.
How does it affect our divorce if the lender refuses to refinance?
Nadia's Question: Part of our divorce agreement is based on the fact that my husband's name needs to be removed from mortgage. Unfortunately, the bank has refused to refinance. In what way does this affect the rest of our agreement?
Brette's Answer: It doesn't affect the agreement, unless one of you wants to return to court to have it modified based on the situation with the bank.
Can he take the home back if I can't refinance the loan?
Diana's Question: We have been divorced for about 4 years. He didn't want the mobile home so in court papers it says it's mine. He wants me to get his name off the loan or refinance. I can't because my credit isn't good. Can he take it away from me?
Brette's Answer: No. Ownership and financing are two separate issues.
Can I be compensated if he failed to refinance?
Michele's Question: According to our divorce agreement, my husband was supposed to refinance the house, take my name off, and pay me ½ the equity within 60 days. It has been 90 days so far and he has done nothing. He was turned down for refinance and will have to take out a loan on the house his grandmother gave him. Meanwhile, he is renting out the house we lived in. Am I entitled to any compensation (1/2 the rent he collects) because I'm still on the mortgage? He is in contempt of court already, and he said the bank said it could take another 2 months.
Brette's Answer: Yes, you can go back to court and file for contempt, violation, or enforcement, but many people are in this situation and the court can't make the process happen any faster. Yes, you should be entitled to half of the rent.
What if he didn't refinance the mortgage after divorce?
Wendy's Question: My ex-husband was court ordered to refinance the marital home and assume all financial responsibilities of the home, and he says he says he has no intention of doing so. I think the problem is that his credit is poor and the home will not appraise for the amount of the original loan. I went to an attorney and he said "you're screwed because a judge cannot force someone to refinance". If that is the case, then how can a judgment have no legal standing?
Brette Answers: The problem is the judge can say he has to refinance, but the judge cannot force a bank to give him a loan. Therefore the judge can't force it to happen. The judge has jurisdiction over your ex (not any banks) and you can return to court and have him held in contempt, but if he has credit so bad that he doesn't qualify, there's not much that can be done.
How do I ensure I'll get my equity share if my ex refinances?
Tasha's Question: My husband wants to "buy out" my interest in the family home and refinance the mortgage and home equity loan in his own name. How can I guarantee that I will get my portion of the equity, especially if I sign a quit claim deed.
Timothy's Answer: If one spouse wants to keep the marital home that is jointly owned, the other spouse may negotiate a "buy out option" in which the equity in the house is traded for a matching amount of equity in something else.
You should consult an attorney before you sign any legal documents. I cannot stress enough how important it is to have your divorce judgment or separation agreement include specific language about your refinancing plans and a contingency plan should the spouse who receives the home is unable to obtain a new mortgage. Too often, we see cases where the spouse who moved out and executed a quitclaim deed run into financial difficulties due to issues that are caused by problems with refinancing.
The equity you receive in exchange for allowing your husband to keep the marital home should be well documented so there is no confusion regarding what assets you retain and what assets your husband retains after the divorce is final.
How can I get my share of the equity if he can't refinance?
Cindy Asks: My ex-husband is supposed to pay me $6100 of the home's equity, which he would get from refinancing the home. He's been told by several lending institutions that he cannot refinance, and his financial plan shows no available money to pay this back. He is indicating that he can't pay this until he is able to refinance (in 40 months). How can I get my equity if he claims not to have the financial resources?
Brette's Answer: The problem is that refinancing is not up to your husband. The court can order him to attempt to refinance, but if he doesn't qualify, the court cannot order a bank to do it. If he's not able to refinance you can ask to have the terms of the settlement changed to reflect this - perhaps he could pay you a monthly amount until he is able to refinance. I suggest you talk with your attorney about what options are available to you. Good luck.
Can he contest the amount he receives when I refinance?
Rhonda's Question: My divorce states I was awarded the home and associated debt and that I would refinance and receive cash out and divide the cash out 50/50 at closing (or sell and split the proceeds 50/50). After 3 years, I am now ready to refinance as I want to keep my home. My ex is giving me a hard time stating he doesn't like the amount. Can he take me back to court over this? I am ready to meet the terms of the divorce, so what is there to contest?
Brette's Answer: If your order says you can keep the home with a refi then you can keep it. He can always seek to modify the order but not liking it is not a reason the court will consider.
Should my fiancé buy the house if I don't qualify to refinance?
Cathy's Question: My divorce decree stated that I must refinance the mortgage on the family home to remove my ex-husband's name by a certain date. I cannot refinance that quickly due to an upside-down equity situation, but my lender said that I should sell the house to my fiancé instead. This way, my kids get to stay in their home and my ex-husband would be free of the financial liability. Is there a downside of this scenario?
Brette's Answer: The downside is your fiancé would own the house, not you. If you break up it would be complicated to unwind since this would be considered separate property for him.
© WomansDivorce.com | Updated March 4, 2023